Product Details
Color Details
Size DetailsFrequently Asked Questions
Are the Oakley Holbrook Metal 4123 sunglasses prescription-ready?
What is the difference between Oakley Holbrook Metal and the original Holbrook?
What size face does the Oakley Holbrook Metal 4123 fit?
How does Oakley Prizm lens technology work?
Do Oakley Holbrook Metal sunglasses provide UV protection?
Can I replace the lenses in my Oakley Holbrook Metal 4123?
Compare With Similar Frames
How the Oakley Holbrook Metal 4123 Sunglasses stacks up against the closest alternatives we carry.
- Lighter weight—more comfortable for all-day wear and high-activity use
- More water and sweat resistant due to O-Matter plastic construction
- Easier lens swapping for customization
- Larger fit—59mm lens width vs 55mm, better for wider faces
- More vertical coverage (45.5mm lens height vs 43mm)
- Made from lightweight O-Matter plastic for all-day comfort
- Hybrid design—O-Matter front with metal temples for a unique look
- Lighter than the full-metal Holbrook Metal
- Combines the durability of plastic lenses with the refined look of metal arms
Read the full comparison
Oakley Holbrook Metal 4123 vs. Original Holbrook 9102 vs. Holbrook XL 9417
Choosing between Holbrook models comes down to material preference, fit, and style. Here's how the Holbrook Metal 4123 stacks up against the most popular alternatives in our collection.
Holbrook Metal 4123 vs. Original Holbrook 9102
The Holbrook Metal 4123 and the original Holbrook 9102 share the same iconic square shape, keyhole bridge, and vintage-inspired design—but the materials make all the difference. The Metal features a lightweight stainless steel frame with adjustable nosepads and Hollowpoint hinges (no screws to loosen), while the 9102 is made from O-Matter plastic, Oakley's proprietary nylon composite that's lighter, more flexible, and highly sweat-resistant.
If you prioritize a refined, dressed-up aesthetic and want adjustable nosepads for a custom fit, the Holbrook Metal is the better choice. It feels sturdier and more premium, and the metal construction transitions easily from outdoor adventures to urban settings. However, if you're looking for the lightest possible frame for all-day wear, high-activity use, or hot, sweaty conditions, the original Holbrook 9102's O-Matter plastic is more comfortable and easier to clean. The original also allows for easier lens swapping and starts at a lower price ($124.50 vs. $180).
Holbrook Metal 4123 vs. Holbrook XL 9417
The Holbrook XL 9417 is the go-to option for anyone who loves the Holbrook design but needs a larger fit. It features a 59mm lens width (vs. 55mm on the Metal 4123) and 45.5mm lens height (vs. 43mm), providing more coverage and a better fit for wider faces. The XL is made from O-Matter plastic, so it's lighter than the Metal and better suited for active use.
If you have a wider face (around 145–147mm face width) or prefer an oversized look with more vertical coverage, the Holbrook XL is the right choice. It's also more affordable, starting at $141.38. However, if you have a medium to large face and prefer the refined look and feel of metal construction with adjustable nosepads, the Holbrook Metal 4123 offers a more sophisticated aesthetic and a more customizable fit.
Holbrook Metal 4123 vs. Holbrook Mix 9384
The Holbrook Mix 9384 is a hybrid design that combines an O-Matter plastic front with metal temples—perfect for buyers who can't decide between the original and the Metal. It's lighter than the full-metal Holbrook Metal 4123 but heavier than the all-plastic 9102, and it offers a unique two-tone aesthetic.
If you want the best of both worlds—the durability and lens-swapping ease of plastic with the refined look of metal arms—the Holbrook Mix is a strong middle ground. However, if you prefer a unified, all-metal construction with a more consistent premium feel, the Holbrook Metal 4123 is the more cohesive choice. Both are similarly priced, so the decision comes down to whether you prefer hybrid styling or full-metal refinement.
Our Recommendation
The Oakley Holbrook Metal 4123 is the best choice for buyers who want the iconic Holbrook design in a refined, durable metal frame with adjustable nosepads and a sophisticated aesthetic. It's ideal for medium to large faces and transitions seamlessly from outdoor adventures to everyday wear. If you need a larger fit, go with the Holbrook XL 9417. If you want the lightest frame for high-activity use, choose the original Holbrook 9102. And if you're drawn to a hybrid design, the Holbrook Mix 9384 splits the difference.
At a Glance
Oakley Holbrook 9102 Sunglasses
Pros:
- Lighter weight—more comfortable for all-day wear and high-activity use
- More water and sweat resistant due to O-Matter plastic construction
- Easier lens swapping for customization
- Lower starting price ($124.50 vs $180)
Cons:
- Feels less premium and sturdy than the metal version
- No adjustable nosepads—less customizable fit
- Plastic construction may feel less refined for dressier occasions
Oakley Holbrook XL 9417 Sunglasses
Pros:
- Larger fit—59mm lens width vs 55mm, better for wider faces
- More vertical coverage (45.5mm lens height vs 43mm)
- Made from lightweight O-Matter plastic for all-day comfort
- Lower starting price ($141.38 vs $180)
Cons:
- Plastic construction instead of metal—less refined aesthetic
- May feel oversized on medium faces
- No adjustable nosepads like the Metal version
Oakley Holbrook Mix 9384 Sunglasses
Pros:
- Hybrid design—O-Matter front with metal temples for a unique look
- Lighter than the full-metal Holbrook Metal
- Combines the durability of plastic lenses with the refined look of metal arms
- Similar price range ($146.66–$286)
Cons:
- Mixed materials may not appeal to purists who want all-metal or all-plastic
- Heavier than the original Holbrook but lighter than the Metal
- Less consistent aesthetic compared to the unified metal construction of the 4123